It didn’t attract her, but it got me one of the best blowjobs I ever received.
I was in my early 20s and a neighbor girl who would hang out sometimes and party with us came over, told me it was her birthday, and asked if I wanted to hang out. I told her I was alone and just watching TV on my day off, so we sat down and smoked a joint. She then leaned over and said the best birthday gift I could give her is if I let her suck my cock. Well shit, you don’t really say no to that, especially since I was single and hadn’t had any play in like a year. She immediately whips out my dick and is stoked that I’m not circumcised. She says she has a fetish for foreskin, and has only gotten to play with one other uncut guy. She proceeds to spend the next hour teasing and playing with my dick, taking her sweet time to edge me before finally letting me cum, and she swallows it all.
We smoked another joint and she went home, and then she moved like a week later.
Fast forward 10 years and my wife and I walk into Olive Garden and she is the hostess. She immediate says hello and says my name, my wife throws eyes at me and asks how we know each other. She says she was friends with one of my old roommates. Thank god.