Ok, spoke with Admin and we did reconsider our position based on what people have said. In the end I was not persuaded and he is of the same opinion as me.
When this forum was first established, it was created as a place for members to share links to porn content featuring foreskin play or favourable talk plus relevant non-porn content such as interviews, info, news, etc. I’m well aware that other people like different aspects of this.
We created tags for things like humiliation and BDSM and we have been pretty tolerant in allowing some pro-circ talk videos in Humilation and (for example) foreskin torture in BDSM. I think we’ve taken a reasonably broad approach to this although we’d both be unconcerned if these types of content were not on here. There’s other porn that I’m interested in but it’s not relevant to this forum so I don’t post it here and obviously we won’t be creating tags for it.
That’s how we feel about videos featuring circumcised penises - they’re not relevant to this forum - therefore we won’t be creating a pro-circ tag. Sorry.