Hello all, new here. I wanted to add my few experiences as well. A little background of myself; around my early teens I learned that there was a stigma about being uncut, so it was a source of insecurity (to a small degree I still worry about it). With that being said, thankfully my experiences have all been positive, albeit few.
My “first” was with my crush from high school, although several years afterwards. It was only crappy because she was with someone else at the time, so the entire time we were intimate was at someone else’s expense (for what it’s worth, turns out he’s a total douche). After a night of drinking, we had moment where she gave a brief bit of oral. We didn’t hang out for a bit, as neither of us were sure how to deal with what just happened. I ended up going over a few days later and to nobody’s surprise, things ended up getting intimate anyway. She mentioned that she remembers that I was “different,” which led to me explaining that I was not circumcised, and that struck her curiosity a bit and she wanted to see it again. Apprehensive, but horny (lol), I sat at the edge of the couch and she toyed around with it a bit. I don’t remember what exactly we talked about meanwhile, but she was pretty careful with it. I told her that she could retract the foreskin tight or pull it forward towards her and either way, it felt good stretching it. The part I remember better is when I told her that she could inflate it like a balloon. She really enjoyed that one, especially since she noticed how much I reacted as she did it. Getting a “balloon” from someone else was like, a dream-come-true for me then.
It obviously went up in flames eventually, but it was fun while it lasted. There’d be many times where we’d be headed back to her place after dinner and she’d just turn to me and ask “can I play with your dick?”, and she’d proceed to play with my overhang and slide her finger into the foreskin.
My “Second” was initially bothered by my foreskin, and I remember her even asking me why I wasn’t circumcised (clearly, expressing her disappointment). She made excuses for not giving BJs and by the 3rd time I recognized it was something we needed to talk about. Eventually we got passed it and she ended up being a real foreskin fan once she started to realize how good it made me feel and that we didn’t need lube for sex. One of my favorite memories was when we took a can of whipped cream to inflate my foreskin and she slowly sucked it out, and another time where she stuffed it full of candies.
Both of these partners were really great experiences for me. I still talk to both of them; the first doesn’t talk about when we were intimate, but my 2nd does occasionally. Both of them gave my penis the nick name “Trunks” (I may have been a little influence here, lol), and took advantage of my longish foreskin. The biggest downside of teaching them the “balloon” trick was that they would do it to avoid swallowing.
There was a third experience, who actually said she preferred foreskin. The most I ever got from her was a hand job. I felt like there was a lot of sexual tension between us but, unfortunately, it never escalated (her kids were always around).
